Reflection

7 Questions to Ask Yourself Before Making a Big Life Decision

A practical guide to slowing down a difficult choice, noticing what is actually keeping you stuck, and finding a clearer next step.

By Garrett Becker Garrett's Dev Desk Guided reflection guide
← Back to Decision Untangler

There is usually a point in a big decision where I have thought about it enough that I am no longer completely sure which thoughts are useful. I have the practical facts, the pros-and-cons list, the opinions I asked for, the opinions I did not ask for, and probably a few imaginary conversations with my future self.

That is usually not when I need another person to tell me what to do. I probably need to get some of the noise out of the way and figure out what I actually think.

I have started liking questions for this because a good question does not add another opinion. It just turns the decision slightly and lets you look at it from another angle.

Here are seven I would keep nearby for the decisions that refuse to leave you alone.

1. If nobody else ever knew what I chose, would my answer change?

I love this question because it removes an entire imaginary audience from the room. Nobody will be impressed by your choice, nobody will be disappointed, and you will never have to explain why you did what you did.

Obviously, real decisions can affect other people, and their needs may genuinely matter. I am not suggesting that we pretend otherwise.

But there is a difference between considering someone and performing for them. If your answer changes once nobody is watching, I would be curious about that.

Try removing the audience

If nobody else ever knew what I chose, would my answer change?

This does not erase real responsibilities. It simply helps you notice how much of the decision belongs to you and how much belongs to the imagined reaction around it.

2. Which option would I regret never trying?

I do not think we should organize our entire lives around avoiding regret. Sometimes the responsible choice really is the quieter one, and sometimes the thing that sounds exciting would actually be a terrible fit.

Still, there are certain possibilities that keep tapping you on the shoulder. You can make a very convincing case for why you should ignore them, and somehow they are still there a month later.

Ask yourself how you would feel if that door closed tomorrow. Relief is interesting, but so is disappointment.

Neither one automatically tells you what to do. It just gives you another piece of yourself to consider.

3. Which option feels more comfortable, and what am I getting from that comfort?

I think “get out of your comfort zone” is one of those phrases that sounds good until you actually think about it. Sometimes my comfort zone contains people I love, routines that keep me sane, financial stability, and a life I genuinely enjoy.

I do not need to blow all of that up just to prove that I am growing.

But comfort can also be sneaky. Familiarity can start doing a lot of the work in an argument simply because changing something feels harder than leaving it alone.

So I like asking what the comfort is giving me. If it is protecting something I value, great; if it is mostly protecting me from uncertainty, that is worth knowing too.

4. What exactly am I afraid of?

“This scares me” is a terrible piece of information because it could mean almost anything. I would rather make the fear get specific.

Am I afraid I will lose money? Am I afraid I will fail? Am I afraid someone will think I made a ridiculous choice, or that I will move somewhere new and feel lonely?

Once I know what the fear actually is, I can do something with it. Maybe I need more information, maybe I need a backup plan, or maybe I simply need to admit that doing something new is going to feel uncomfortable for a while.

Make the fear explain itself

What exactly am I afraid of?

Fear is useful information. It just does not deserve to cast the deciding vote without explaining itself first.

5. Which option helps me grow in a way I actually care about?

Growth is another word that gets treated like it is automatically good. More responsibility, more money, a bigger title, a harder challenge, and a busier calendar can all look like progress from the outside.

But maybe the growth you actually need right now is learning to protect your time. Maybe it is doing more creative work, becoming more independent, spending more time with people you care about, or building a life that is a little less exhausting.

That is why I would not just ask which option offers more growth. I would ask which one helps you grow in a direction you actually want to go.

There is a big difference.

6. How much of this decision is coming from “I should”?

“I should” is one of those phrases that can quietly take over an entire decision. I should take the promotion, I should stay, I should go, I should want this opportunity, or I should choose the sensible option.

Sometimes there is a very good reason behind the “should.” We have responsibilities, commitments, and people whose needs matter to us.

But sometimes the sentence ends with something much fuzzier. “Because that is what people do,” “because they will be disappointed,” or “because it seems like the kind of thing I am supposed to want.”

I think it is worth finishing the sentence. I feel like I should choose this because…

Whatever comes next probably deserves a closer look.

7. What do I think I already know?

This one makes me a little uncomfortable, which is probably why I like it. After all the research and arguments and lists, what do I think I already know about the decision?

Maybe I know which option I want but do not like how risky it feels. Maybe I know I want the safer choice but feel like I am supposed to be more adventurous.

Or maybe I genuinely have no idea yet.

That is allowed too. The goal is not to force some hidden inner wisdom to produce an answer on command.

It is simply to notice whether I have been quietly leaning somewhere while simultaneously doing an excellent job of arguing myself out of it.

You do not need all seven questions to agree

If five of these questions point toward Option A and two point toward Option B, please do not turn this into another spreadsheet and declare Option A the winner. That would be impressively efficient, but it would also miss the point.

I think the interesting part is why the answers are different. Maybe Option A keeps appearing around comfort and obligation while Option B keeps appearing around curiosity and growth.

Now we are getting somewhere.

The decision may still be hard, but at least you have a better picture of what is making it hard. You are not just choosing between two options anymore; you are looking at the different things those options represent to you.

That is really the thinking behind Decision Untangler. I wanted it to be a quiet, private place that asks questions like these from different angles without having AI jump in and announce what you should do.

Sometimes a big decision does not need another opinion.

Sometimes you need a few good questions, a little less noise, and enough room to notice what you have been saying all along.

Want to sit with the questions?

Try working through the decision one question at a time.

Decision Untangler is a free, private reflection tool that asks guided questions about the choice you're holding. It doesn't use AI to tell you what to do — it helps you notice what keeps showing up in your own answers.

Your decision and answers stay in your browser. No account and no AI-generated advice.

About the author

Garrett Becker builds small, thoughtful, privacy-conscious tools through Garrett's Dev Desk. Decision Untangler grew out of a simple idea: sometimes the most useful thing when you're stuck isn't another answer, but a better question.